Migrants’ vocational guidance, and transition into VET in Switzerland
Chair(s): Alexandra FELDER (SFUVET, Switzerland)
Discussant(s): Alexandra Felder (SFUVET, Switzerland)
This symposium proposes to gather the expertise of researchers on the topic of vocational guidance and integration of people with migration background from different disciplines.
Multiple factors are pivotal for vocational guidance and integration: At the macro-level, they refer to the migration and integration policies, and continuing education and training facilities implemented by the government.
At a meso-level, institutional organisations supporting people with migration background in the construction of their career paths are crucial, as well as the inter-institutional collaborations in cantons and communes.
At the microlevel, the support depends on the quality of the relationships between the different stakeholders and individuals. These relationships themselves are linked to the institutional context, but also the professionals’ conception of their roles, their social representations, and their openness to adapt to the person’s expectations. In a counseling setting exists an unequal power issue where the counselor or social worker can be seen as having the authority in terms of the decisions and outcomes.
Individual past, backgrounds and living conditions also have a strong influence on people with migration background’s ability to choose a training path. Their social and cultural origins, previous training, residency status, as well as the length of their residence in Switzerland, are all important factors in their vocational choice.
This symposium therefore considers vocational or training choice to be influenced by a multitude of factors. It discusses to what extent the stakeholders involved can have an impact on vocational trajectories of people with migration background considering external circumstances that can be both supportive and restrictive. It also examines to what extent people with migration background can act on or overcome the various constraints and injunctions. These processes will be discussed in depth in the presentations addressing initial vocational training, as well as considering the differences between various migration groups.
Presentations of the Symposium
Trajectories of Involuntary Career Change Following Migration: A Qualitative Longitudinal Study
Caroline Éliane Brazier, Roxane Coquoz, Jonas Masdonati
University of Lausanne
Since the mid-1980s, career transitions have become increasingly complex, often intertwining with challenges in other life domains such as family, health, leisure, mobility, and social integration. For people who have migrated, career transitions can be particularly demanding, with obstacles like diploma non-recognition, language barriers, and discrimination. These obstacles can lead to an involuntary career change (ICC), which may trigger occupational downgrading and income reduction, thus jeopardizing their careers and social integration. Drawing on life course approach, we address the long-term trajectories of migrant people forced to change careers and the interplay between their career transition and other life domains. A longitudinal qualitative study was conducted with five individuals undergoing ICC following migration to Switzerland, with each participant interviewed four times over 3.5 years. Trajectory-based thematic analysis was used to identify within-person evolutions and shared trajectory patterns. Findings revealed diverse ICC experiences, ranging from regaining to losing control over one’s career. Participants exhibited both linear and non-linear interdependence patterns across their life domains, in particular between family and professional domains. These results emphasize the need for both systemic and extended career counseling that accounts for the multifaceted challenges faced by individuals who have migrated and track their diversified career trajectories.
Vocational Choices and Career Trajectories Under Constraint: Exploring Refugee Integration in the Swiss Labor Market
Stéphanie Cardoso
University Lausanne
In the context of increasingly complex migratory flows and professional integration challenges, this presentation examines the professional integration of refugees in Switzerland, focusing on provisionally admitted individuals whose stay is rarely temporary. Using a qualitative methodology based on a psychosocial approach, we examine the interplay of macro-, meso-, and micro-level factors shaping vocational choices and career trajectories.
At the macrolevel, a documentary analysis explores the evolution of integration policies and their influence on refugees’ access to the labor market—an issue at the forefront of current policy debates. At the mesolevel, semi-structured interviews shed light on the dilemmas social workers face in balancing institutional demands with individualized support. At the microlevel, narrative interviews reveal systemic barriers and resource gaps that hinder refugees’ ability to build meaningful career paths.
This study directly addresses the symposium's key questions by exploring how structural constraints, societal representations, and professional practices intersect to shape vocational choices. It highlights the strategies refugees and their counselors employ to navigate the tensions between individual aspirations and labor market demands, and offers actionable insights into creating more fair and sensitive guidance practices to better support this vulnerable population’s career development.
Tensions during the implementation of integration policy in Switzerland: The challenges surrounding “fast and sustainable” integration
Ihssane Otmani
Haute école de travail social, Fribourg
This article explores the tensions arising from implementing integration policy in Switzerland. Relying mainly on the experiences and perceptions of 23 street-level bureaucrats (SLB) and 29 refugees in the Canton of Vaud in Switzerland, it identifies the dynamics at work during the process of integration, in particular how the focus on quick labor market integration of refugees, shapes both refugees’ integration tra-jectories and SLBs understanding of their role and function. The article closely examines the tensions experienced on both sides; among others, these spring from expecting “fast” integration. It finds that SLBs strive to ensure “fast and sustainable integration” by promoting rapid access to vocational training and employment. This approach often causes friction between SLBs, who recognize the shortcomings of this approach without seriously challenging it, and refugees, who either adapt to the expectations of “fast and sustainable integration” or rely on their own resources to gain support for their more ambitious projects.
What do you want to do in 10 years? Exploring refugees' career aspirations
Barbara E. Stalder
Bern University of Teacher Education
Refugees often face the challenge of having their previous qualifications disregarded, disrupting their career aspirations (Udayar et al., 2021; Wehrle et al., 2018). In Switzerland, university access is largely blocked, and entering the labour market depends on vocational qualifications. To support access to VET, the Swiss government established the PAI programme, a one-year pre-vocational programme for refugees and late-arriving migrants (Aerne & Bonoli, 2021; Kammermann et al., 2022). The programme is occupation-oriented, equipping participants with academic, practical, and transferable skills to prepare them for an apprenticeship. This presentation examines whether refugees see VET as a desirable pathway, given that in many countries, it holds low status (Billett et al., 2022). Using data from the national PAI study (2019–2025; N=4733) (Stalder et al., 2024; Stalder & Schönbächler, 2024), we explore how career aspirations are shaped by participants' asylum status, age, and family responsibilities, their PAI learning experiences, and the career support they received. Findings show that many refugees have high aspirations. While some wish to remain in their PAI occupational field, others seek further education. Coaches, trainers, and teachers play a key role in guiding them. Overall, the PAI successfully engages refugees in VET and opens career pathways.