Given data generated by an observable stochastic process, we study how to construct statistically optimal decisions for general stochastic optimization problems. Our setting encompasses non-standard data structures, including data originating from heterogeneous sources or from randomly evolving data-generating mechanisms. We propose a decision-making approach that identifies optimal decisions for which a specific notion of risk of shifted regret decays to zero at a prescribed exponential rate. This optimal decision arises as the solution to a multi-objective optimization problem, which reflects asymptotic behavior properties of the data-generating process. Central to our framework is a rate function that characterizes this behavior via a Laplace principle, thereby generalizing standard concepts from large deviation theory. Our general formulation enables our approach to account for data from uncertain distributions and recovers classical results in data-driven decision making under uncertainty as special cases, including distributionally robust optimization. Moreover, our method enables decision-makers to systematically balance a desired rate of asymptotic risk decay against a potential loss in statistical consistency of the resulting data-driven decision. We demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed approach through illustrative examples from operations research, such as the newsvendor problem, under aleatoric uncertainty induced by heterogeneous data sources.